By Cofe Zuo    Photo：CANVA

Background: The Core Difference Between Two "Temporary Importation" Paths

In international trade, businesses often need to bring commercial samples, exhibition goods, or professional equipment abroad for short-term display, testing, or use. To avoid the duties and complex formalities of permanent import, "temporary importation" is the preferred solution. In practice, there are two primary models: using an ATA Carnet and going through standard temporary import customs procedures. While they serve a similar purpose, their operational logic and applicability are fundamentally different.

The ATA Carnet, known as the "Passport for Goods," is an internationally recognized customs document valid in over 87 countries and territories. It is based on the ATA Convention and the Istanbul Convention. Its core feature is "issued once, accepted in multiple countries." After obtaining a Carnet in their home country, businesses can use it for temporary export and import declarations in multiple member countries without needing to post a cash deposit for duties and taxes in each.

Standard Temporary Importation is handled according to the domestic customs regulations of the destination country. Businesses must apply each time, often providing a cash deposit, bond, or other form of guarantee equivalent to the potential duties and taxes to secure temporary duty-free admission. The processes, time limits, and documentation requirements vary from country to country.

The table below highlights the key differences to aid your decision-making:

Operational Process: The Standardized Path Using an ATA Carnet

Once you choose the ATA Carnet, a clear operational workflow is key to success. The process can be summarized in three stages: Application, Utilization, and Finalization.

Stage 1: Assessment & Application (Start at least 1 month in advance)

Evaluate & Plan: Confirm all destination and transit countries are ATA members. Finalize the goods list, values, estimated dates, and transport method.

Prepare Application: Submit the application to your national guaranteeing/issuing association (e.g., the China Council for the Promotion of International Trade). Key materials include: a completed application form, a detailed goods list (with serial numbers, values, weight), and guarantee proof (deposit or insurance bond).

Receive the Carnet: Upon approval, you receive a paper ATA Carnet booklet. It contains a cover page, a green General List, white vouchers for export/re-import, and yellow vouchers for import/re-export.

Stage 2: Customs Utilization (The Critical Execution Phase)

Export from Home Country: Present the Carnet (white export voucher) and goods to home customs for endorsement.

Temporary Import Abroad: Upon arrival, present the Carnet (yellow import voucher) to foreign customs. After verification, they will endorse and release the goods without collecting duties.

Re-export from Foreign Country: After use, present the goods and Carnet (yellow re-export voucher) to customs when leaving.

Re-import to Home Country: When goods return, present the Carnet (white re-import voucher) to home customs to close the loop.

Stage 3: Finalization & Discharge of Guarantee

Within the Carnet's validity (usually 1 year), return the fully endorsed Carnet to the issuing association for final discharge. Once processed, your guarantee (deposit) is released. If goods are not re-exported, the guarantee will be claimed to pay foreign duties.

Common Pitfalls & NG Cases: Avoiding Costly Mistakes

Even with a good process, practical oversights can lead to delays, fines, or loss of guarantee.

NG Case 1: Misuse of Goods

A company used an ATA Carnet for a precision instrument declared for "exhibition demonstration." Overseas, the client used it for small-batch paid sample processing. Local customs deemed this "disguised processing/manufacturing," seized the goods, and demanded full duties and penalties.

Analysis: ATA Carnets strictly forbid use for direct production or commercial sale. Using demonstration goods for paid processing changes the fundamental nature of the temporary admission.

NG Case 2: Missing Endorsements & Overstay

A company exhibited in three European countries. The Carnet was properly endorsed in the first two. When entering the third country, due to a flight delay, the staff couldn't find a customs officer to stamp the re-export voucher from the second country. Months later, during Carnet discharge, the chain was broken. Furthermore, some items overstayed the Carnet's 1-year validity in the final country. The company faced discharge issues and owed duties for the overstay.

Analysis: Every customs endorsement is crucial to create an auditable trail. A missing stamp creates liability ambiguity. Also, strictly adhere to the Carnet's validity and national time limits; overstay risks treatment as permanent import.

NG Case 3: Major Discrepancy Between Goods List and Actual Items

The Carnet application listed "1 industrial robot, value $50,000." For export, the company decided last-minute to include a $20,000 set of critical spare modules without amending the Carnet. Foreign customs found the discrepancy, suspected misdeclaration, and detained the goods for investigation, severely impacting the exhibition schedule.

Analysis: The Carnet's goods list is a legal document. It must match the physical items exactly. Any significant change in quantity, model, or value requires a formal amendment from the issuing association before shipment.

Practical Advice & Checklist

To ensure a smooth temporary import project, follow this advice and use the checklist at key stages.

Core Recommendations:

Plan Early: Initiate the Carnet application 4-6 weeks in advance for complex cases.

Seek Expert Help: For first-time use or high-value/special goods, consider using an experienced freight forwarder or customs broker. They can advise on country-specific risks.

Document Integrity: The original Carnet is the only valid document. Ensure every customs stamp is clear and complete. Keep photocopies/scans throughout the journey.

Strict Compliance: Use goods only for the declared purpose abroad. Set calendar reminders for re-export deadlines.

Pre-Departure Checklist for ATA Carnet Shipments:

Destination Check: Are all destination and transit countries ATA members?

Goods Compliance: Are the goods strictly for "commercial samples," "exhibition," or "professional equipment"? Do they exclude consumables, gifts, or items for direct sale/production?

List Accuracy: Is the goods list (description, model, S/N, quantity, value, weight) 100% accurate?

Timeline Feasibility: Can the entire trip (transport, use, return) be completed within the Carnet's 1-year validity?

Guarantee Arranged: Have you confirmed the guarantee method (deposit or insurance) and amount with the issuing association?

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Q1: How do the time limits for an ATA Carnet differ from standard "temporary import" procedures?

A1: The ATA Carnet itself is valid for a maximum of 1 year, and goods must be re-exported within this period. In contrast, under China's temporary import/export regulations, the standard admission period is 6 months, extendable upon approval, but the total period generally cannot exceed 24 months. Other countries have their own varying rules which must be checked individually.

Q2: What if the goods are damaged or lost overseas?

A2: This is a serious situation. You must immediately file a police report for loss, and notify both the ATA issuing association and the local customs. For damage, the remnants usually must still be re-exported. For loss, you must declare "non-normal re-export" to foreign customs and will likely be liable to pay duties on the lost goods. Your guarantee will be used to cover this tax payment.

Q3: As an Authorized Economic Operator (AEO), do we get additional convenience when using an ATA Carnet?

A3: Yes and no. AEO status can provide significant convenience for standard temporary import procedures, such as waiver of guarantee requirements. However, for the ATA Carnet itself, you still must provide a guarantee to the issuing association (e.g., CCPIT). Nonetheless, your AEO status will still provide general benefits like prioritized customs clearance and lower inspection rates during the actual export/import declarations, which can indirectly streamline the overall ATA process.

Q4: When might standard temporary import procedures be more suitable than an ATA Carnet?

A4: Two main scenarios: First, when goods are traveling to only one country (especially a non-ATA member). Second, when the required temporary import period is likely to exceed one year. For example, some countries' national procedures (like the U.S. TIB entry) may allow temporary admission for equipment for large projects for up to 3 years, which offers more flexibility than the Carnet's 1-year limit.

Appreciate if you could share TGL Blog among your friends who are interested in first-hand market information of supply chain and updated economic incidents.