By Landy Yao    Photo：CANVA

Cargo damage and quantity shortages are common challenges for import/export companies and logistics professionals in global supply chains. When such incidents occur, they not only cause direct financial losses but can also disrupt production schedules, customer relationships, and business reputation. In the chaos, panic or incorrect responses may lead to the loss of critical evidence, complicating subsequent claims. Therefore, establishing a clear, actionable response process is essential.

I. The Golden Emergency Protocol: Securing Evidence is Paramount

The initial response after an incident often determines the success of a claim. The core principle is: all actions prioritize "securing evidence."

1. Immediate Notification and Scene Preservation:
   • If an abnormality is discovered during cargo pickup—whether at a port, airport, or warehouse—the first step is to immediately notify the on-site carrier representative​ (e.g., shipping line yard staff, truck driver, airport cargo terminal personnel). Request a joint inspection and prevent the cargo from being moved or the scene disturbed.
   • If there is obvious damage, wet stains, deformation to the packaging, or if the seal number does not match the documents, do not sign a clean receipt. Instead, annotate the exception in detail on the delivery note and seek the delivering party's countersignature.
2. Initiate Joint Survey, Obtain Key Written Proof:
   • Insist on a joint survey​ with the carrier (or their agent). This is the crucial step to transform "a problem you identified unilaterally" into "a fact confirmed by both parties."
   • After the survey, it is imperative to obtain a formal cargo damage/shortage certificate issued and signed by the carrier, such as:
     • Damage/Shortage Report:​ Details the specific nature, quantity, location, and possible cause of the damage/shortage.
     • Sea Protest/Master's Report:​ In cases potentially under carrier exemption (e.g., heavy weather), the captain may submit this report. A copy can serve as evidence of the incident's occurrence.
   • This document is the cornerstone​ for any subsequent claim against the carrier and holds far more weight than your own photographs.
3. Comprehensive Collection of Visual and Third-Party Evidence:
   • Photography and Videography:​ Document systematically. Take shots from wide angles (the entire cargo stack, container/truck exterior and number) to close-ups (details of damage, condition of goods inside, shipping marks). Video can better demonstrate the context and relationship of the damage to the environment.
   • Appoint an Independent Surveyor:​ For high-value cargo or disputes with potentially complex liability, immediately appoint an independent international inspection company​ (e.g., SGS, BV) to conduct a survey and issue a report. Their professional, impartial stance gives their report strong credibility in legal and negotiation contexts.

II. Navigating the Liability Maze: Who is Responsible?

Once evidence is secured, quickly analyze liability to identify the correct party to claim against.

• Carrier Liability:​ This is the most common target for cargo claims. Under international conventions like the Hague Rules, the carrier has a duty to properly and carefully load, handle, stow, carry, keep, care for, and discharge the goods during its "period of responsibility" (typically "tackle to tackle" or "port to port"). Liability may arise from improper stowage, inadequate lashing, poor ventilation, or an unfit hold. However, pay close attention to the exceptions​ (e.g., fault in navigation or management of the ship, acts of God, war) and limitation of liability​ (e.g., 666.67 SDR per package or unit) in the bill of lading's terms and conditions.
• Insurance Company Liability:​ If the cargo owner has purchased cargo transportation insurance, a claim can be filed with the insurer according to the policy terms. Coverage under "All Risks" offers the broadest protection. Claiming from the insurer often provides a more standardized process. After indemnifying the insured, the insurer acquires "subrogation rights" to pursue recovery from the liable party, relieving the cargo owner of that burden. This is the most effective form of risk transfer.
• Multimodal Transport Operator/Freight Forwarder Liability:​ In door-to-door shipments, the party that contracts with you for the entire transport is the NVOCC or MTO. As the contracting carrier, they are responsible for the entire journey. You can claim against them, and they will, in turn, seek recovery from the actual carrier at the leg where the loss occurred.
• Buyer/Seller Liability:​ Reference the trade contract (e.g., Incoterms® rules). For instance, under FOB terms, the buyer is responsible for arranging the main carriage and bears the transit risk, so the buyer typically claims against the carrier or insurer. If a shortage is a "short shipment" (short-loaded at the origin), liability may lie with the seller under the sales contract.

III. Initiating the Formal Claim: The Paper War and the Race Against Time

Claims are a "paper war." Complete, compelling documentation is key to success. Strict adherence to legal and contractual time limits is non-negotiable.

1. Issue Notice of Claim:​ Within the time limit specified in the bill of lading or waybill (for sea transport, typically within seven consecutive days after delivery of the goods, or the date when they should have been delivered), submit a written notice of loss or damage​ to the carrier. Even if the final loss amount is not yet determined, this preserves your right to claim from procedural forfeiture.
2. Prepare a Complete Claim Dossier:​ A full set of claim documents typically includes:
   • Claim Letter:​ Formally states the claim, amount, and basis.
   • Commercial Documents:​ Original bill of lading/waybill, commercial invoice, packing list, sales contract.
   • Core Evidence:​ Carrier-issued damage/shortage report, independent survey report.
   • Proof of Value:​ Invoice and payment proof showing the goods' value.
   • Statement of Loss:​ Detailed breakdown of the value of damaged/lost goods, estimated depreciation, and reasonable expenses incurred to mitigate the loss (e.g., survey fees, sorting/repair costs, extra storage).
   • Visual Evidence:​ Organized photos and videos.
3. Negotiation and Dispute Resolution:
   • Submit the complete dossier formally to the liable party to begin negotiations. The carrier or its insurer may raise objections or offer a settlement based on limitation of liability.
   • Base negotiations on evidence, clearly pointing out the party's breach of duty of care. Engage professional logistics claim consultants or lawyers if necessary.
   • If negotiations fail, be acutely aware of the time bar for suit. The time limit for claims against a carrier for carriage of goods by sea is typically one year​ from the date of delivery or the date when delivery should have been made. Legal action (arbitration or litigation) must be initiated before this expires, or the right to recover is lost.

IV. The Smoother Path: Claiming from the Insurance Company

If insured, the process is generally more straightforward:

1. Timely Notification:​ Upon discovering the damage, notify the insurer immediately (often within 10 days) as required by the policy.
2. Submit Claim Application:​ Complete the "Advice of Loss" and "Claim Form."
3. Provide Documents:​ In addition to the commercial and evidence documents, provide the original insurance policy.
4. Cooperate with Loss Assessment:​ Cooperate with the insurer's surveyor for loss assessment.
5. Receive Indemnity:​ Upon agreement, the insurer makes payment. You may need to sign a Subrogation Form, transferring the right of recovery against the liable party to the insurer.

Conclusion and Risk Mitigation Strategies

Prevention is better than cure. To minimize risk, companies should:

• Invest in Robust Packaging:​ Design and test packaging sufficient to withstand common hazards specific to the cargo and transit route.
• Ensure Clear Marking:​ Clear, durable shipping marks and fragile stickers aid identification and prompt careful handling.
• Utilize Insurance Wisely:​ Especially for high-value or fragile goods, insure adequately under "All Risks" and consider additional covers like "War Risks" or "Strikes" as needed.
• Choose Partners Carefully:​ Collaborate with reputable, well-managed carriers, airlines, and freight forwarders.
• Understand Document Terms:​ Before signing a contract of carriage or accepting a bill of lading, understand the liability, exemption, and limitation clauses.

When an incident occurs, calmly and swiftly executing the standard procedure of "Notify, Survey, Document, Notify, Negotiate"—and leveraging professional expertise when needed—is the most effective way to control losses and successfully secure compensation, thereby protecting your legal rights and interests.

Appreciate if you could share TGL Blog among your friends who are interested in first-hand market information of supply chain and updated economic incidents.